[banner]
Manly Arts Day at Hampton National Historic Site
September 18, 2011

report by Rachel Klingberg

The theme of this year's Manly Arts Day at Hampton National Historic Site was "a rare look at self defense 'Victorian style' in Baltimore City and County on the eve of the Civil War." Professor Mark Donnelly and Mr. Steve Huff, assisted by Victor Markland and members of The Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship, taught Civil War-era military, frontier, and urban street fighting. The participants were of all ages and backgrounds, and the instructors have a rare gift for conveying history and for patiently teaching beginners the basics of 19th century combatives.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]
Professor Mark Donnelly and Mr. Steve Huff demonstrating 19th century pugilism

Regrettably I arrived about 45 minutes late, after following some convoluted Mapquest directions, so I missed all but the last few minutes of the first session, American Knife Fighting: Bowie and Beyond with Steve Huff. A park ranger directed me to The Orangery, a small building constructed to grow citrus fruits for the Ridgely family who originally lived on the estate:

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]
A display of antique weapons and gear

Inside students were practicing with wooden Bowie knives, and at the tail end of the class when they put together what they had learned. Afterwards there was a short break and I walked outside to take a better look at Hampton. I felt shy about not knowing anyone there, truthfully, and was glad when Mark Donnelly called out to me, introduced me to his associates, and said they'd make sure I didn't sit on the sidelines watching. And indeed they didn't, so thank you to Professor Donnelly and to his students Noah, John, and Taylor.

I continued my stroll of the grounds. Hampton is a magnificent historic estate, beautifully preserved and maintained. In 1790, its mansion was the largest private house in the United States. By 1820 more than 300 slaves toiled at Hampton, making it one of the largest slave-holding estates in Maryland. It was owned by the Ridgely family for over 150 years, until the National Parks Service purchased it in 1948. I wished I had time to see the interior and the other buildings on the estate. Next time I visit Baltimore, I'll definitely be back.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

We reconvened on the lawn for our next session, Victorian Era Sport Fencing Single Stick with Mark Donnelly, who gave us an overview of single stick and its history as a sport in England. He described its origins as "fencing for peasants" with challenges presented at country fairs. In the 18th century opponents stood at a fixed distance with feet immobile, similar to academic fencing. The goal of a single stick bout was to draw an inch of blood from the opponent's head. A single stick player wrapped his stock around his left hand and tied the ends under his thigh. The left elbow was raised to protect the face, as Professor Donnelly demonstrates below:

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Sherlock Holmes described himself as "a bit of a single-stick expert" and Watson also referred to Holmes as "an expert single-stick player." In the 19th century, single stick was popular at universities, and was used as military training for the sabre. (Here's a video of Bob Brooks, Marshal of the Hotspur School of Defence and Professor Mark Donnelly "using Highland methods prescribed for the basket-hilt broadsword with singlestick.") Professor Donnelly and Mr. Huff demonstrated single stick play slowly for our benefit.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Rattan single sticks were distributed to the participants and we gave it a try, one step beyond striking distance for safety. First we tried at a fixed distance with feet immobile, using a lunging motion to strike and evade, and then with feet mobile, moving linearly. This was a lot of fun, although quite unfamiliar to me, but the Bartitsu workshops I've taken with Professor Donnelly were helpful background. All too soon the session was over and it was time for the house tour. I was sorry to miss it, but my friend picked me up for lunch. Upon my return I took a stroll on the terrace to look at the formal gardens below:

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Front view of Hampton House:
[Manly Arts Day 2011]

A stray photo of Professor Donnelly's students John and Noah; I'm not sure what sort of weapon the latter is wielding; looks like some sort of flail. (Note from Professor Donnelly: "The weapon is Slung Shot - a traditional 18th and 19th century sailor's weapon. Handmade by sailors serving on ships, they were a common tool for aiding in casting lines, but were adapted as weapons in various sizes, especially when carried by sailors on land in foreign ports.")

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

At 1:00 we resumed with Civil War Infantry. A park ranger and re-enactor led us through the McClellan bayonet drill.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

The participants had fun with the drill as it was relatively simple.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]
Photo above by Victor Markland of The Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship

Professor Donnelly and Mr. Huff talked about Civil War bayonets relative to other weapons of the era. Below the professor and his student Noah demonstrate bayonet vs. sabre:

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

As always the participants took a turn. We were encouraged us to give a sort of vengeful "Hah!" as we lunged forward. We practiced bayonetting each other, from a safe distance, of course, lunging forward and back. Professor Donnelly instructed me to leap back with as much vigor as I lunged forward. I recalled my many Systema lessons about withdrawing our motley collection of practice knives (which include a dulled Russian bayonet), which we practice by clasping the blades tightly between flattened palms while our partners practice whip-like or twisting movements to extract them. It may seem rather grim to practice extracting a knife from a corpse, but for self-defense and military purposes, a knife is useless if you cannot retrieve it.

Next up was Civil War Cavalry Training. Victor Markland led us through the eight cuts of the cavalry sabre, first with our hands, then with wooden sabres. I was quite lost for most of these, although I tried lining up my feet with Mr. Markland's but still didn't quite follow along. Certainly I found the sabre the most difficult of the training; all forms of European swordsmanship are quite unfamiliar to me. My background is Systema, a Russian Martial Art, and while the shashka is a traditional Russian weapon, it is not taught as part of modern Systema because the Russian military no longer uses swords. The emphasis is more on the knife, gun, military shovel, and other modern Cold-War-era weaponry; traditional swords and especially the steel-cored Cossack whip are used as a training tools but it is not expected that students will carry these weapons for self-defense or as part of military training.

To simulate horses the participants held folding chairs. I am a lapsed equestrienne and love horses, so I couldn't help but think of the million or more horses who died during the Civil War, not to mention all the various battlefields throughout history. Thankfully horses are rarely used in modern warfare. Professor Donnelly and Mr. Huff explained that the success of the calvalry was largely dependent on the military decision of the officer who commanded them, that all cavalry held their sabres in their right hands, and that that the better horseman had the advantage more so than the better swordsman. It does take a great deal of skill to maneuver even a well-trained war horse into the chaos of battle.

Professor Donnelly and Mr. Huff demonstrated protecting the rider's head, horse's head, horse's flank, and rider's sword arm. I was curious as to how they protected their horse's heads from such a distance; the instructors had said that our chairs were much smaller than actual horses; they were more like Shetland ponies than chargers. Professor Donnelly explained that they leaned forward over their horse's necks, almost in a jumping position, as you can see in this 1895 painting.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

And of course, the audience gave this a try as well. I found this quite daunting and "dismounted" in order to give it a try. Professor Donnelly and Noah were incredibly patient and I managed to get the hang of it once with much coaching:

[Manly Arts Day 2011]
Photo above by Victor Markland of The Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship

We began the next session Plug Uglies and Street Defense. Pt 1 Unarmed - Fisticuffs, criminal "tricks", joint locks etc.. We began with 19th-century pugilism, starting with the structure of the fists with knuckles parallel to the body.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

We learned how to parry a blow and place our partners in a Chancery hold, which a layperson might call a "headlock." Note that Mr. Huff's right leg is placed to prevent Professor Donnelly from stepping out of the hold.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

We also learned how to escape from this hold by opening the chest, and a very nifty way to lock the striking arm by slipping the right hand into the opponent's left elbow as he cocks his arm to strike. I wish I had more photos, but I was too busy learning!

Our final session was Plug Uglies and street defense. Pt 2 armed gangs (Irish Stick), riots and gentlemanly street defense. Mr. Huff instructed us in Irish stick - the shillelagh, a weapon that is synonymous with Irish pride and often mentioned in lore, as in this 1860s anti-recruiting folk song "Arthur McBride," which describes what happens when two Irishmen refuse to "take the King's shilling."

"Oh no," says the Sergeant. "I'll have no such chat,
And neither will I take it from snappy young brats,
For if you insult me with one other word,
I'll cut off your heads in the morning."
And Arthur and I, we soon drew our hogs,
And we scarce gave them time to draw their own blades
When a trusty shillelagh came over their head
And bid them take that as fair warning.
And their old rusty rapiers that hung by their sides,
We flung them as far as we could in the tide,
"Now take them up, devils!" cried Arthur McBride,
"And temper their edge in the mornin'!"

I have only one rather unimpressive photo from the Irish stick portion taught by Mr. Huff. Although I generally take photographs at martial arts seminars, the most interesting bits tend to go unphotographed as it's difficult to focus on learning and photographing. Generally I take a lot of photographs in the beginning and tend to forget about my camera as the day goes on.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

As with single stick, the bit of Vigny cane instruction from Professor Donnelly's Bartitsu workshops was helpful background. I wished I could have spent more time practicing, but the idea behind Manly Arts Day was more of a sampler to give us all a taste of 19th century combatives. The final portion was about the Pratt Street Riots, a bloody street conflict between Union soliders and Confederate sympathizers that marked the beginning of the Civil War. A couple of re-enactors, pictured below, incited the crowd.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Participants gamely played the role of the Union regiment marching down the street, while the Secessionists "rioted," booing and throwing tennis balls in lieu of bricks. One re-enactor told us the remarkable story of a man in the crowd who found himself picking up a brick and throwing it angrily at the Union troops, who continued to march stoically. He was so impressed with their courage that he boarded the next train and volunteered his service for the same army at which he had just thrown the bricks!

[Manly Arts Day 2011]
Photo above by Victor Markland of The Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship

Thus concluded Manly Arts Day, and the instructors invited us to remain to ask questions about anything that piqued our interest. Since I had missed the morning's Bowie knife instruction, I was curious to see Mr. Huff explaining about the use of the tomahawk in frontier combatives.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

He explained that the weight of its head could quickly fatigue the arm, and so the Native Americans wielded it in a smooth, flowing, fluid manner rather than chopping with abrupt motions that would be wearying after only a few minutes.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

It is apparent that Mr. Huff has much experience with this weapon, and was so comfortable with the tomahawk that it was a treat to watch him explain its uses: not merely cutting but also destroying the joints as well as locking and hooking. He showed the various ways it was wielded, gripping the end, the middle, or right below the head.

[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Targeting the hand with the tomahawk:
[Manly Arts Day 2011]

Although I was tired, I could have stood listening to Mr. Huff for hours. I would love to learn more about frontier and Native American combatives and clearly he's an expert.
[Manly Arts Day 2011]

My ride had arrived and I didn't want to keep my friend waiting. We couldn't be more different - she spent the morning shopping - but she's always such a good sport about my obsession with martial arts and combatives, ferrying me Systema seminars and to army surplus stores and letting me stay with her anytime there's an interesting event in the area. So I thanked the instructors and returned home tired but enthusiastic about all the interesting material that was presented. It was a marvelous experience and I wish to extend my gratitude to Professor Mark Donnelly and his students; to Mr. Steve Huff, Mr. Victor Markland, the The Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship, and the park rangers and staff of Hampton National Historic Site.

Here I am standing in front of the mansion. I tried to make my usual 1890ish/steampunk clothing a bit more 1860s in keeping with the Civil War theme. I didn't think a skirt would be practical, so I ended up looking somewhat Colonial in my velvet knee breeches, jabot, and a shirt I wear to the office. By the 1860s men wore long high-waisted pants, but I'm a woman, so a bit of speculative attire for "manly arts" is not amiss!

[Manly Arts Day 2011]